A statistical approach to latitude measurements: Ptolemy's and Riccioli's geographical works as case studies

Santoro, Luca

doi:10.5194/hgss-8-69-2017

Articles | Volume 8, issue 2

https://doi.org/10.5194/hgss-8-69-2017

© Author(s) 2017. This work is distributed under
the Creative Commons Attribution 3.0 License.

https://doi.org/10.5194/hgss-8-69-2017

© Author(s) 2017. This work is distributed under
the Creative Commons Attribution 3.0 License.

Articles | Volume 8, issue 2

07 Aug 2017

| 07 Aug 2017

A statistical approach to latitude measurements: Ptolemy's and Riccioli's geographical works as case studies

Luca Santoro

Viewed

Total article views: 3,211 (including HTML, PDF, and XML)

HTML	PDF	XML	Total	BibTeX	EndNote
2,184	887	140	3,211	139	212

HTML: 2,184
PDF: 887
XML: 140
Total: 3,211
BibTeX: 139
EndNote: 212

Views and downloads (calculated since 07 Aug 2017)

Month	HTML	PDF	XML	Total
Aug 2017	163	28	5	196
Sep 2017	53	11	2	66
Oct 2017	49	11	1	61
Nov 2017	69	9	2	80
Dec 2017	62	13	0	75
Jan 2018	45	14	2	61
Feb 2018	45	16	3	64
Mar 2018	33	8	0	41
Apr 2018	36	13	1	50
May 2018	48	11	1	60
Jun 2018	35	12	0	47
Jul 2018	35	3	0	38
Aug 2018	36	4	0	40
Sep 2018	32	11	1	44
Oct 2018	29	2	0	31
Nov 2018	43	13	0	56
Dec 2018	32	6	1	39
Jan 2019	37	12	0	49
Feb 2019	32	8	1	41
Mar 2019	37	6	1	44
Apr 2019	22	5	0	27
May 2019	22	8	0	30
Jun 2019	22	8	0	30
Jul 2019	28	9	2	39
Aug 2019	30	6	0	36
Sep 2019	30	7	1	38
Oct 2019	24	6	0	30
Nov 2019	23	9	0	32
Dec 2019	24	3	1	28
Jan 2020	26	5	2	33
Feb 2020	29	5	1	35
Mar 2020	23	9	0	32
Apr 2020	34	11	1	46
May 2020	13	6	0	19
Jun 2020	56	9	0	65
Jul 2020	54	32	33	119
Aug 2020	32	9	3	44
Sep 2020	39	5	0	44
Oct 2020	14	11	0	25
Nov 2020	4	6	1	11
Dec 2020	12	9	0	21
Jan 2021	9	11	0	20
Feb 2021	9	10	0	19
Mar 2021	9	12	0	21
Apr 2021	7	11	0	18
May 2021	9	13	0	22
Jun 2021	9	5	0	14
Jul 2021	5	3	0	8
Aug 2021	5	8	0	13
Sep 2021	7	5	3	15
Oct 2021	4	21	2	27
Nov 2021	18	26	4	48
Dec 2021	15	6	0	21
Jan 2022	6	9	1	16
Feb 2022	10	5	3	18
Mar 2022	11	5	1	17
Apr 2022	4	2	0	6
May 2022	4	8	1	13
Jun 2022	4	5	0	9
Jul 2022	2	1	0	3
Aug 2022	11	3	1	15
Sep 2022	6	4	1	11
Oct 2022	5	2	0	7
Nov 2022	11	9	0	20
Dec 2022	7	1	0	8
Jan 2023	1	7	0	8
Feb 2023	9	3	0	12
Mar 2023	9	3	0	12
Apr 2023	18	2	0	20
May 2023	18	4	1	23
Jun 2023	9	7	1	17
Jul 2023	3	6	2	11
Aug 2023	3	4	2	9
Sep 2023	4	2	0	6
Oct 2023	7	4	0	11
Nov 2023	4	1	0	5
Dec 2023	8	3	1	12
Jan 2024	3	0	3
Feb 2024	5	3	0	8
Mar 2024	3	3	0	6
Apr 2024	6	3	3	12
May 2024	5	4	1	10
Jun 2024	13	4	3	20
Jul 2024	16	3	3	22
Aug 2024	5	6	3	14
Sep 2024	4	3	1	8
Oct 2024	12	6	0	18
Nov 2024	17	1	0	18
Dec 2024	14	4	3	21
Jan 2025	10	9	3	22
Feb 2025	16	6	1	23
Mar 2025	19	5	3	27
Apr 2025	5	8	1	14
May 2025	8	8	1	17
Jun 2025	30	27	1	58
Jul 2025	7	12	2	21
Aug 2025	13	15	1	29
Sep 2025	28	8	2	38
Oct 2025	12	17	0	29
Nov 2025	22	16	4	42
Dec 2025	24	23	2	49
Jan 2026	30	47	3	80
Feb 2026	26	15	3	44
Mar 2026	29	10	5	44
Apr 2026	10	1	1	12

Cumulative views and downloads (calculated since 07 Aug 2017)

Month	HTML	PDF	XML	Total
Aug 2017	163	28	5	196
Sep 2017	53	11	2	66
Oct 2017	49	11	1	61
Nov 2017	69	9	2	80
Dec 2017	62	13	0	75
Jan 2018	45	14	2	61
Feb 2018	45	16	3	64
Mar 2018	33	8	0	41
Apr 2018	36	13	1	50
May 2018	48	11	1	60
Jun 2018	35	12	0	47
Jul 2018	35	3	0	38
Aug 2018	36	4	0	40
Sep 2018	32	11	1	44
Oct 2018	29	2	0	31
Nov 2018	43	13	0	56
Dec 2018	32	6	1	39
Jan 2019	37	12	0	49
Feb 2019	32	8	1	41
Mar 2019	37	6	1	44
Apr 2019	22	5	0	27
May 2019	22	8	0	30
Jun 2019	22	8	0	30
Jul 2019	28	9	2	39
Aug 2019	30	6	0	36
Sep 2019	30	7	1	38
Oct 2019	24	6	0	30
Nov 2019	23	9	0	32
Dec 2019	24	3	1	28
Jan 2020	26	5	2	33
Feb 2020	29	5	1	35
Mar 2020	23	9	0	32
Apr 2020	34	11	1	46
May 2020	13	6	0	19
Jun 2020	56	9	0	65
Jul 2020	54	32	33	119
Aug 2020	32	9	3	44
Sep 2020	39	5	0	44
Oct 2020	14	11	0	25
Nov 2020	4	6	1	11
Dec 2020	12	9	0	21
Jan 2021	9	11	0	20
Feb 2021	9	10	0	19
Mar 2021	9	12	0	21
Apr 2021	7	11	0	18
May 2021	9	13	0	22
Jun 2021	9	5	0	14
Jul 2021	5	3	0	8
Aug 2021	5	8	0	13
Sep 2021	7	5	3	15
Oct 2021	4	21	2	27
Nov 2021	18	26	4	48
Dec 2021	15	6	0	21
Jan 2022	6	9	1	16
Feb 2022	10	5	3	18
Mar 2022	11	5	1	17
Apr 2022	4	2	0	6
May 2022	4	8	1	13
Jun 2022	4	5	0	9
Jul 2022	2	1	0	3
Aug 2022	11	3	1	15
Sep 2022	6	4	1	11
Oct 2022	5	2	0	7
Nov 2022	11	9	0	20
Dec 2022	7	1	0	8
Jan 2023	1	7	0	8
Feb 2023	9	3	0	12
Mar 2023	9	3	0	12
Apr 2023	18	2	0	20
May 2023	18	4	1	23
Jun 2023	9	7	1	17
Jul 2023	3	6	2	11
Aug 2023	3	4	2	9
Sep 2023	4	2	0	6
Oct 2023	7	4	0	11
Nov 2023	4	1	0	5
Dec 2023	8	3	1	12
Jan 2024	3	0	3
Feb 2024	5	3	0	8
Mar 2024	3	3	0	6
Apr 2024	6	3	3	12
May 2024	5	4	1	10
Jun 2024	13	4	3	20
Jul 2024	16	3	3	22
Aug 2024	5	6	3	14
Sep 2024	4	3	1	8
Oct 2024	12	6	0	18
Nov 2024	17	1	0	18
Dec 2024	14	4	3	21
Jan 2025	10	9	3	22
Feb 2025	16	6	1	23
Mar 2025	19	5	3	27
Apr 2025	5	8	1	14
May 2025	8	8	1	17
Jun 2025	30	27	1	58
Jul 2025	7	12	2	21
Aug 2025	13	15	1	29
Sep 2025	28	8	2	38
Oct 2025	12	17	0	29
Nov 2025	22	16	4	42
Dec 2025	24	23	2	49
Jan 2026	30	47	3	80
Feb 2026	26	15	3	44
Mar 2026	29	10	5	44
Apr 2026	10	1	1	12

Latest update: 21 Apr 2026

Short summary

Historical geographical works typically contain many latitude measurements of locations: all show measurement errors and some of these refer to lost cities. How can we estimate errors? How can we know the right position of lost cities? This work shows a general approach to give a scientific answer to these questions in two particular case studies: Ptolemy's Geography and Riccioli's work on geography.