Classical Antiquity Origin of Spatial Data Underlying Portolan Charts: How Pietro Vesconte Might Have Assembled the Carta Riccardiana Utilising Maps in Marinus of Tyre’s projection

Abstract. The remarkably accurate representation of coastlines on late mediaeval portolan charts has garnered significant scholarly interest in uncovering the origin of their spatial data, with the prevailing hypothesis suggesting that they are authentic products of their time, created by synthesising numerous shipborne bearing and distance measurements. The pursuit of those answers also prompted the establishment and advancement of a cartometric approach, through which they can be attained with quantitative accuracy. This study is based on cartometric analyses and historical evidence, providing a comprehensive examination of the anonymous Carta Riccardiana portolan chart, presumably created by Pietro Vesconte between 1300 and 1325. It posits a paradigm shift regarding the late mediaeval origin hypothesis, tangibly indicating that the conventional geometry of portolan charts was likely developed by late mediaeval copyist-cartographers who utilised regional maps from classical antiquity, originally made in the projection of Marinus of Tyre calibrated to their mid-latitudes as inputs, which they partially scaled and gradually tilted, using a map in Ptolemy’s first projection as a reference model. Concurrently, the article provides a historical overview of the most significant cartometric studies in the field, critically analysing their unique systemic parameters that have influenced various hypotheses regarding the origin of portolan charts—specifically, the systemically induced similarity with the modern map in the Mercator projection, which is, in the case of the Carta Riccardiana, at least, a misleading notion.